I was originally going to write an emotionally meaningful post tonight, but I did my ecology volunteering this morning, so I've been up since 4:45 a.m. And my family is in town. So emotional post next time, polishing post tonight.
I haven't had a ton of story publications, but I have been reading slush for a professional fiction market for... um... six years now. As such, I'm bringing all my tips from that angle.
(Since the category is polished, I'm going to assume you've proofread. Don't be that writer with the otherwise awesome story with a typo in their very first paragraph. This actually happened this month, and almost every slush reader mentioned that in their comment. It's not the kind of thing that really makes a difference between publishing and not... but it looks bad.)
1. Read the guidelines, and follow them. It seems like I shouldn't have to say this. And yet, there are a startling number of people who don't do it. I know some of it is accidental, such as uploading the wrong file. And sometimes you're uploading the story at 10 pm at night when the baby has been screaming all day long because she's teething, and you can't remember your own name, let alone how many words your story is. Unfortunately, that situation is impossible to see from my end, and we see so many blatant disregards of our rules. I think it feels to me like a lack of respect. If you don't respect us enough to follow your guidelines, why should we give you the respect of paying you professional rates for your story?
2. Be professional in your demeanor. Writing is art. Publishing is art with a side of business. It ends up sometimes as this messy collision between insecure artists (aren't we all?) and people trying to make enough money to keep their publication afloat so they can keep publishing good stories. It astonishes me the number of people who put down their work, or who try to make jokes in their cover letters, or who say "this is something I wrote in an hour last weekend." I don't even know what that last one means; does it mean you haven't proofread it yet? Is the worth of a story really determined by the amount of time it took you to write? Just pretend your story is going out on a job interview. You wouldn't make jokes or insult yourself in a job interview, so don't do it in a cover letter for your story.
Those two will get you consideration without being kicked out. But actually getting published? That's much tougher to pin down. Some of the biggest mistakes I see, especially for us, is stories that are the wrong size for their current word count, either too large or two small. And every story needs a beginning, middle, and end. It makes a difference.
There is one thing that seems to matter more than the others, so I'll quote a previous post by an authority on the subject*:
3. Don't worry about trends. Write what matters to you. It's hard to set hard and firm rules about what stories or trends I hate. Because every time I do so, someone comes along with an exception to the rule, and I have to shut my mouth all over again. Sheer originality is a good thing too, but an old idea well-told can be a glorious thing.
The real kicker is a good tale combined with good emotion. One of my slushers has been complaining lately about the number of stories featuring difficult situations faced by wide-eyed children. It's something we see often – where the writer has gone for the biggest emotional punch possible. Sort of like, "It'd be sad if the main character had cancer, but it would be EVEN SADDER if he got the cancer while rescuing puppies from communists!" (You see this type of thing in anime all the time too – all the characters have to have a horrifically tragic backstory). The instinct is understandable. Emotion is what attaches us to the stories we read. However, I'm beginning to think that it's not the amount of the emotion that matters. Rather, it's the truth of that emotion, and how well the writer projects it.
Hopefully those thoughts are of use to at least some of you! Now if you'll excuse me, I'm going to go sleep for hours and hours and hours.
*Me, from a few months back ;)
Showing posts with label publishing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label publishing. Show all posts
Thursday, April 16, 2015
Thursday, April 3, 2014
The Trouble with Dystopians - Part 1
I've
been meaning for a while now to write a post about dystopian YA fiction. I finished several dystopian series at once near the end of last year, right around the time the second Hunger Games movie came out. And now, with the Divergent movie having done so well, it seems like the first time to finally get to finishing this post.
Dystopians have been popular for a while, but it really kicked off with the Hunger Games. Theories as to why they're so popular range from high school is like a rigid, dystopian society, to dystopians hold a mirror to society, to my personal favorite - recent dystopian fiction tends to follow the Hero's Journey. Oh, and apparently Edward Snowden is a lot like Katniss. Anyway, the Hero's Journey theory actually makes a lot of sense - I don't think the Hero(ine?)'s journey is ever going to go out of style.
Speaking of style issues, let's look at the series I'm going to be discussing:
Dystopians have been popular for a while, but it really kicked off with the Hunger Games. Theories as to why they're so popular range from high school is like a rigid, dystopian society, to dystopians hold a mirror to society, to my personal favorite - recent dystopian fiction tends to follow the Hero's Journey. Oh, and apparently Edward Snowden is a lot like Katniss. Anyway, the Hero's Journey theory actually makes a lot of sense - I don't think the Hero(ine?)'s journey is ever going to go out of style.
Speaking of style issues, let's look at the series I'm going to be discussing:
In a distant, dark future, a sudden event changes a young woman's life, pulling her away from everything she knows. The society as she's known it has always been bad, but it turns out its worse than she thought, and she finds herself at the center of a revolution, and a race to save what's left of society. But is the revolution everything it seems? Who are the good guys? And in fighting the revolution, will she has to sacrifice the boy she loves?
Believe it or not, I actually hadn't noticed this pattern (clearly modeled after the Hunger Games) until I started writing tonight. I'd mentally grouped these books together to compare them more for the plot structure, but apparently they stuck together in my mind for others as well. In case you're wondering, the series are:
The Chemical Garden Trilogy, Lauren DeStefano
The Divergent Trilogy, Veronica Roth
The Matched Trilogy, Allie Condie
The Hunger Games Trilogy, Suzanne Collins (of course)
From what I've read so far, the Crewel, Delirium, and Under the Never Sky series (and possibly Shatter Me**) should probably be in this group, but I haven't finished them yet, and I'm far too lazy to do so by the next post. In any case, for this first post, I'm going to talk about patterns and shared ideas and fiction.
I don't think similarities are necessarily a bad thing. It's a little startling to me how similar these dystopian novels are on that basic level, now that I'm aware of it. But they're certainly not the first time an idea has been recycled. For one, there's the hilarious comparison
of Pocahontas and James Cameron's Avatar that's been around for a while. And it's not like I'm going around saying, "Oh darn, too many awesome strong female characters who save the world!"
And in Fantasy, we have the whole Tolkien subgenre. And Arthurian stories, which I've never liked. I mean, it's a never ending pattern of "everyone betrays each other and then they die." In most stories, you have hope that something good will happen at the end, but with Arthurian retellings, it's pretty much set that everyone dies tragically.
Then, of course, there's urban fantasy. I'm pretty sure Laurell K. Hamilton and Anita Blake
are solely responsible for the current trends, though I'm too lazy to Google it to see if I'm right. And yes, I know Emma Bull's War of the Oaks is the real first urban fantasy. But Hamilton is responsible for the vampire/witch/shapeshifter/half (or full) faerie/necromancer/wizard, who lives in a city and hunts the local vampire/witch/shapeshifter/half (or full) faerie/necromancer/wizards, all while fending off her attraction for a darkly mysterious vampire/witch/shapeshifter/half (or full) faerie/necromancer/wizard. Oh, Anita
Blake. I remember how awesome you were before you gathered your male harem. All
those interesting moral thoughts you had about religion and intimacy? Whatever!
Forget those!Though I think I'd probably hate those books if I started reading
them now. But at the time, I loved them, and Anita was in a class of her own.
So why do we keep seeing so much of the same? I think some of it is comfort - my comfort reads are historical romance. Not sure why, because they're some of the most formulaic of all genres, but there's something soothing about pretty dresses and a guaranteed squishy happy ending.
But I think there's another aspect at work: publishers will sell what is likely to be successful. That's not necessarily a critique. Their job is to publish books they know people will buy. It can go deeper than that though. Here is an excellent and thoughtful post (WARNING: contains adult language). from the review site Dear Author (they have a ton of amazing and insightful articles there on publishing, self-publishing, authors behaving badly, and more... apart from all the book reviews).
For those not in the mood to read a post with adult language, or who don't want to click on one more freaking link for this post, here is the conclusion to the article:
Assumptions about what readers want not only reinforce the sexist status quo, but they create homogenized books. Books in which we know what’s going to happen before it happens.... And as the comments from self-policing authors attest, these established norms are self-perpetuating. They’re writing what they’ve read, what they expect to read.
What do readers want? Perhaps we won’t truly know ourselves, until we get to experience all the possibilities.
What do you think? What would you like to see more of in your traditionally published fiction?***
Maybe it will be urban science fiction, with the android/cyborg/alien/space pirate/three-headed space lobster who hunts android/cyborg/alien/space pirate/three-headed space lobsters and fights off her attraction to a android/cyborg/alien/space pirate/three-headed space lobster.
One can only hope not.
Coming up next week: the second half of the dystopian post, where I talk about what does and does not work in this particular brand of dystopian fiction.
*Blogger flags dystopian as misspelled - and offers 'utopia' as the only correction. STOP TRYING TO WHITEWASH EVERYTHING, GOOGLE! I will not bow to your evil empire!
**A large part of the reason I haven't read this one yet is because the heroine's name is Juliette. I think that would confuse me too much right now.
***Yes, self-publishing is its own thing that might be the solution, but I'm not going to talk about it in this post, because it's late and I'm lazy.
Saturday, October 26, 2013
The Dreaded Back Cover
(I apologize in advance for the lack of pictures. I'm on vacation and not using my regular computer, and I can't quite figure this one out. When I get back to my regular computer, maybe I'll come back and pretty this post up.)
Alchemy was just the start of my publishing adventures. In January, I'm publishing another book called Hidden Magic. It was the first novel I ever wrote, and somehow it managed to maintain its hold on me through the whole learning curve. It would be fun if I could find my first draft and compare it to the final project--I doubt more that 20% of it survived the editing process, and possibly less than that. It has taken nearly six years to get it to this point.
But here I am, knee deep in watching Darren Boekweg create my cover. It is a gorgeous cover, and I can't wait to share it with you. But a few days ago he asked what I wanted on the back cover. Eek.
When I went on the radio to promote Alchemy a couple of weeks ago, I was terrified. Like couldn't sleep terrified, and this was why: There was a pretty good chance someone was going to ask me what our book was about. Do you know the feeling? Even if you've got your elevator pitch prepared, it is so easy to get lost in the convoluted twistings and turnings that seem necessary to explain character, setting, theme, and plotline.
Before I went on the radio, I turned to my daughter, who luckily was able to distill about five minutes of stuff I thought I had to explain before I could even begin to discuss what the book was about into one very natural sounding sentence.
Writing a back cover is that same kind of daunting. I've been doing my own research on back covers. Mostly, I went through the house and gathered up a pile of my favorite books that seem to match the genre of Hidden Magic. I also grabbed the books in my TBR pile. Here's what I found:
A lot of the books by very famous authors don't have a blurb about their book on the back. Instead, they have a "praise for" section where they cite reviews of previously published books. I am adding this to my list of reasons to become a successful author--so that I don't have to write my own back covers anymore.
Megan Whalen Turner has a huge picture of herself on the back of the dust cover of my copy of The Queen of Attollia, and nothing else. A few other books had most of the back devoted to an author bio.
Books later on in a series often had very few words. For example, the back of Allegiant says, "One Choice: One Choice Can Define You. One Choice Can Destroy You. One Choice Can Transform You." For someone picking up her book for the first time, that is next to no information. But those words are carefully chosen to stir the hearts of people who are already fans of the series. Another reason to get famous. Tag lines like that can get so famous I don't even need to name the book: "One ring to rule them all..."
But my favorite back covers had a quote from the book or a short synopsis, and in many cases, they had both. I know from happy experience that a well-written back covercan get people interested in a book. In fact, I'm a huge believer in using that space to sell your story's romance, if it has one.
I went so far as to count the words on the backs of the stack of my books that had quotes or synopses. None of them had more than 150 words. More than half had close to that number of words, and most of those had a quote from the book with a tiny synopsis that mostly put that quote into context.
Those with just a synopsis were usually closer to about 75 words, with a lot of white space on the back. White space is so important! If the back of the book is filled with words, people (read: me) don't bother to read it. There was often a different font for the hook, so that people's eyes are drawn to it, and then are interested enough to read the whole thing.
I haven't found the magic words to put on the back of Hidden Magic yet. I'll know when I get there, because the people who read it will love it as much as they loved the back of Alchemy.
I've got an assignment for you, should you choose to accept it. You can either:
A. Go through the back of the books you love and notice what works for you. Then write your answers in the comment section.
OR
B. If you already have some great advice about back covers, please share it.
We could become the definitive word on back covers!
Alchemy was just the start of my publishing adventures. In January, I'm publishing another book called Hidden Magic. It was the first novel I ever wrote, and somehow it managed to maintain its hold on me through the whole learning curve. It would be fun if I could find my first draft and compare it to the final project--I doubt more that 20% of it survived the editing process, and possibly less than that. It has taken nearly six years to get it to this point.
But here I am, knee deep in watching Darren Boekweg create my cover. It is a gorgeous cover, and I can't wait to share it with you. But a few days ago he asked what I wanted on the back cover. Eek.
When I went on the radio to promote Alchemy a couple of weeks ago, I was terrified. Like couldn't sleep terrified, and this was why: There was a pretty good chance someone was going to ask me what our book was about. Do you know the feeling? Even if you've got your elevator pitch prepared, it is so easy to get lost in the convoluted twistings and turnings that seem necessary to explain character, setting, theme, and plotline.
Before I went on the radio, I turned to my daughter, who luckily was able to distill about five minutes of stuff I thought I had to explain before I could even begin to discuss what the book was about into one very natural sounding sentence.
Writing a back cover is that same kind of daunting. I've been doing my own research on back covers. Mostly, I went through the house and gathered up a pile of my favorite books that seem to match the genre of Hidden Magic. I also grabbed the books in my TBR pile. Here's what I found:
A lot of the books by very famous authors don't have a blurb about their book on the back. Instead, they have a "praise for" section where they cite reviews of previously published books. I am adding this to my list of reasons to become a successful author--so that I don't have to write my own back covers anymore.
Megan Whalen Turner has a huge picture of herself on the back of the dust cover of my copy of The Queen of Attollia, and nothing else. A few other books had most of the back devoted to an author bio.
Books later on in a series often had very few words. For example, the back of Allegiant says, "One Choice: One Choice Can Define You. One Choice Can Destroy You. One Choice Can Transform You." For someone picking up her book for the first time, that is next to no information. But those words are carefully chosen to stir the hearts of people who are already fans of the series. Another reason to get famous. Tag lines like that can get so famous I don't even need to name the book: "One ring to rule them all..."
But my favorite back covers had a quote from the book or a short synopsis, and in many cases, they had both. I know from happy experience that a well-written back covercan get people interested in a book. In fact, I'm a huge believer in using that space to sell your story's romance, if it has one.
I went so far as to count the words on the backs of the stack of my books that had quotes or synopses. None of them had more than 150 words. More than half had close to that number of words, and most of those had a quote from the book with a tiny synopsis that mostly put that quote into context.
Those with just a synopsis were usually closer to about 75 words, with a lot of white space on the back. White space is so important! If the back of the book is filled with words, people (read: me) don't bother to read it. There was often a different font for the hook, so that people's eyes are drawn to it, and then are interested enough to read the whole thing.
I haven't found the magic words to put on the back of Hidden Magic yet. I'll know when I get there, because the people who read it will love it as much as they loved the back of Alchemy.
I've got an assignment for you, should you choose to accept it. You can either:
A. Go through the back of the books you love and notice what works for you. Then write your answers in the comment section.
OR
B. If you already have some great advice about back covers, please share it.
We could become the definitive word on back covers!
Tuesday, November 6, 2012
Why Opening Pages Get Rejected
![]() |
| Picture from Stock xchange |
Besides there are much more pressing matters to discuss like
reasons why an agent might reject your first few pages.
This is an
awesome blog post I came across the other day by author Anne Mini. Apparently, she went to a writer’s conference
and attended a session where attendees submit the first two pages of their
manuscripts to be read out loud, and three agents on the panel tell the audience
when they would stop reading and why.
Anne, being awesome and amazing, wrote down every reason they gave for
not reading on and every reason they gave to read on. She explains the whole thing much better on
her blog post which is really insightful, so make sure you go read it.
There are seventy-four reasons given to not read on, and
only eight reasons given to read on. I
don’t think this is a checklist of things to make sure you don’t do, and a lot
of them are vague and subjective and while these are reasons that might stop
these particular agents, others may not be bothered by them at all.
But there are a few take home lessons I got from the
seventy-four reason not to read on, so I thought I’d share them with you.
1. All those little rules that we writers teach each other, really
do bug agents. In fact, several of them
may stop an agent from finishing the first page of your manuscript (#11-don’t
start with a scene that ends up being a dream, #13-avoid cliché phrases, #21-
don’t have a character looking in the mirror to describe him/herself, #
27-don’t open with flashbacks, # 52-aviod saidisms, #70-show don’t tell, just
to name a few).
2. Don’t try to create false tension by withholding
information. There are several examples
of this #16, 17, 18, 19, and 20. These
include unnamed items, person, or facts.
As a reader, I also find this very frustrating.
3. There seems to be these little tricks we writers use to make
writing easier for us, and the agents are on to us and don’t like it. Here are a few examples:
#15. "The opening had a character do something that
characters only do in books, not real life. Specifically singled out: a
character who shakes her head to clear an image, 'he shook his head to clear
the cobwebs.'" This is something I do
actually do in real life. I do
subconsciously shake my head when I’m deep in thought, and I’ve
caught myself doing this, so I really don’t think that this action is
unrealistic. But I’m guessing agents
must see this kind of phrasing a lot. I’ve
used it in my writing. I think that this
could be a crutch because it is such an easy way to transition from a character
being deep in thought to returning to what is presently happening in the
story. So I do think this is something
to watch out for.
#60. "The writing falls back on common shorthand
descriptions. Specifically singled out: 'She did not trust herself to speak,' 'She didn’t want to look…'" Once again, I
don’t think that these type of phrases should never be used, but they must be
overly used or used in the wrong way to annoy agents enough that they won’t read
on.
4. Conflict, conflict, conflict. A story really needs some sort of conflict
right up from the start (see # 6, 32, 33, and 41). But don’t try too hard (#4, 42, 65, and 69).
#1 "A non-average character in a situation you wouldn’t
expect."
#4. "The scene was emotionally engaging"
#5. "The voice is strong and easy to relate to."
#6. "The suspense seemed inherent to the story, not just how
it was told."
#8. ”There was something going on beyond just the surface action.”
#8. ”There was something going on beyond just the surface action.”
But I think this whole list can be summed up in that there
was something interesting going on on the page.
Whether it was mysterious, emotional, or engaging.
I know this is a lot to take in and it feels daunting thinking about all the reasons your story might be rejected so quickly, so I want to leave you with my take on how stories should begin.
I believe every story has the right place to begin, and I think for probably most of us aspiring and even published writers, it is really, really hard to find that place. Sometimes you have to write the whole story before you see it, sometimes you need a little insight from your beta's, and sometimes the beginning just comes to you from the moment you start typing.
I think it is really important to find that perfect spot and not fall into the trap of easy openings like waking up, character dreaming, or looking in the mirror. And once you find that spot, you need write it honestly, in the moment of the character, and let the plot points and characterization and world-building fall naturally into place. Don't force information on the reader, but don't keep it from them either. Let the story unfold naturally.
And I think if you do that, then it won't matter if you violate one or two or even ten of these reasons for rejection. You can read this list and shrug it off because that is where and how your story begins.
Not that any of this is as easy as it sounds, but writing is never easy.
~MaryAnn
Wednesday, October 3, 2012
Real Life, Really
I apologize that this post will have to be necessarily brief.
Very brief.
Sometimes, as we've discussed before, real life has to come first.
That's one reason why I found this post by Nathan Bransford very comforting and, in a way, freeing.
Thanks for understanding!
Oh, and I'll just go ahead and post The Publishing Process in GIF Form from Nathan, too. I know you've seen it - who hasn't? But it still makes me laugh. Spock is my fav - it is so completely me when I write. What part do you relate to right now?
~Susan
Very brief.
Sometimes, as we've discussed before, real life has to come first.
That's one reason why I found this post by Nathan Bransford very comforting and, in a way, freeing.
Thanks for understanding!
Oh, and I'll just go ahead and post The Publishing Process in GIF Form from Nathan, too. I know you've seen it - who hasn't? But it still makes me laugh. Spock is my fav - it is so completely me when I write. What part do you relate to right now?
~Susan
Sunday, September 30, 2012
We Know Why We Write...Now Why Do We Publish?
![]() |
| My incredibly dorky phone |
Yesterday, I sent off my first submission in two years. As a result, I have checked my email no less than fifty times. Possibly more. Which is kind of hilarious, considering I just posted about dealing with rejection two weeks ago. The thing is, I'm not afraid of being rejected. I've had rejections in the past, and I survived. I think what I'm really afraid of is being accepted. The thought of being published--and the expectations my family and friends would have of me after that--makes me shake in my boots. (Okay, fine, slippers.)
I think there is a second factor causing me to eye my phone nervously once every ten minutes. I have always said I'd never be able to write a) short stories and b) horror. I am awful at limiting the plot of a story, and more times than not, my short story idea hits 40,000 words before I realize what's happening. At that point I usually shrug and forge ahead. It doesn't really matter if I'm writing a short story or novel. As long as I'm enjoying it, I'm happy.
![]() |
| Add caption |
Then, at the beginning of the month, I had an idea. I'm not going into it here because it is horror, after all, and isn't suitable for polite company. Let's just say it was a persistent idea, and eventually I got to the point that I couldn't ignore it. I sat down to write, and when I finished, I realized that this is the sort of horror story I want to read. It just so happened that a local magazine was looking for stories for their Halloween edition, so I screwed up my courage and sent it in.
Which brings us up to the present. The question pressing on me now is, "What do I do if they like it? What if my family wants to read it?" I think my dad would be fine. He'd buy extra copies and force his co-workers to read it, too. My mom, however, would probably be horrified.
Which is kind of the reaction I was going for, though I'd like to avoid that awkward conversation I'd be stuck having about "writing things my grandparents can't read."
I guess my real question this week isn't "Why do I want to write?" It's more along the lines of, "Why do I want to publish?" I thought I understood, but this panic over submitting has forced me to reevaluate the question. While I work on that, let me ask you:
What's your reason for seeking publication?
Labels:
Horror,
publishing,
Trisha
Friday, September 14, 2012
So...Did You Get That Book of Yours Published Yet?
A couple of weeks ago, MaryAnn wrote this post about self-publishing versus the traditional methods of publishing.
I started writing the year I homeschooled my (then) fifth grader. A
homeschooling magazine published an article about Nanowrimo for young people,
and it looked like it was right up our alley. The more I wrote, the more I realized
that writing was what I had been born to do. I loved my characters and believed
in their story. They were worthy of traditional publishing, and I knew it.
It's something that's been on my mind a lot lately. I started seriously
writing five years ago. Since then, I've written four full manuscripts. Of those, two
probably need to be scrapped completely, one is ready for publication and one is in the editing stage. I'm in the middle of a collaborative novel that I'm
really excited about, and I've got part of a screenplay I'd love to get back
to, if I could ever figure out how to write screenplays (but that's another story). I've written several
short stories, and even won a couple of contests, though I've figured out that
short stories really aren't my thing.
And then it began. I knew exactly who I wanted to have publish my novel, and
they were selling querying time to authors at a writer's conference in a city I
was going to be in during the week I was going to be there. It was kismet!
I paid, memorized my query, met my dream publisher, and listened as she
told me that the market was absolutely saturated with young adult romantic
fantasy at the moment, and that her publishing company was not currently
looking for any. She was kind, and she even stood with me in the hall
afterwards and introduced me to some published authors and another publisher. Of
course it hurt, but I felt like I'd scaled to a new authorial level.
I might have, but I never moved past it. Once or twice I spent a day
finding agents to submit queries to, and I spent some time trying to perfect my
query. I even forced myself to send a few queries out. Jessica Foster (who has
been a guest poster here on The Prosers) blogged about how querying makes her
feel. The video of the cat and the banana described my feelings about querying
so precisely that I hope you'll take the time to go watch it. I thought about
having a link to her post be my whole blog today, but as usual, I found a few
words to add. :^)
I don't want to feel like that cat any longer. Back when I was just
starting on this journey to authorhood, I wanted it to be a lucrative career. But here I
am, five years out, and the truth of the matter is that on a good week I spend
about fifteen hours on writing, and that includes this blog, critiquing other
people's manuscripts, and all the other writerly stuff I do (except the brain
work part. That goes on constantly--sometimes even while I sleep.) Given the other things I have elected to do
with my time, that number isn't going to change. I could spend that time
querying and all the other things I would need to do to get published, but I
would be miserable. I know what
MaryAnn wrote is true--if I want to sell to a lot of people, self-publishing is
going to take a lot of work. But I'm ready to get my books out there, and I've
moved past the place where I want to write a best-seller. What I want to do is write.
~Melanie
What I'm currently reading: Nothing!
Why: Because Legend, by Marie Lu was supposed to keep me occupied until next week, at least. Drat that exciting story line that tricked me into reading all day yesterday.
Tuesday, September 4, 2012
Self-Publishing and Self-Promotion
![]() |
| Picture from stock-xchnge by Andreas Krappweiss |
The concept is so beautiful, like The Field of Dreams. If you write it, they will come.
Only what if they don’t?
I read this
NY Times article the other day on buying positive book reviews (I’m going
to get to that in a minute), but the article claimed that more than 300,000
books were self-published last year, and that number is only going up. It could be more than doubled next year. Granted not all of these books will be in
your genre, but if only 1% of them were, there would be over 3,000 books for consumers to
search through to find your gem. And
that is only including self-published books.
You would also be competing for attention with all the traditionally
published books, which could include every book that has ever been published in
modern times. That is a lot of books
waiting to be bought on Amazon. So how
do you get your book to stand out above the masses?
Self-publishing is so easy, but self-promotion is so tough.
It is hard to proclaim to the world how wonderful your book
is. No one is going to take you
seriously. You can become really
annoying if all you do is talk, tweet, and blog about your book. It is so much better if that comes from
someone else.
Which brings us to the NY Times. According to the article (link above), some authors paid a man
named Todd Rutherford money to write positive reviews for their books. He charged $99 for one review, $499 for
twenty, and $999 for fifty. Before too
long, he started making $28,000 a month.
I think this practice is dishonest and shady, and I feel
that Mr. Rutherford was taking advantage of authors desperate to get some
attention for the books they put their heart and souls into. I seriously doubt
that very many of them actually made that money back in sales. But I do
understand why the authors chose to buy reviews.
Reviews should be for the readers, but good reviews and high
ratings can help sell books because someone else is singing the praise for your
book, making them more trustworthy. However, if you have few or no
reviews, your book isn’t going to look too promising. And if just one of those reviewers gave
you a low score, that is going to substantially affect your book's overall
rating. Furthermore, if other writers
are artificially inflating their positive reviews, this is only going to make your
book look worse than everyone else’s. I
can definitely see the dilemma these writers are in.
Still I don’t think that lying and manipulating consumers is
the way to go even if it has been the corner stone of all advertising. Books aren’t the only products with fake
positive reviews (see the NY Times article above).
I wish I had some real answers on how to get your book out
there in a more honest way, but I don’t.
I’d be horrible at self-promotion which is one of the main reasons I
want to go the traditional route (yes I do know this also requires some self-promotion, but hopefully, I'd get some help). For good advice go to Amanda
Hocking who actually achieved that level of success from self-publishing
that we all dream about. Sheena also did
an excellent
post on how youtube videos go viral and how that can be applied to
books. While I think they both give great advice, it really comes down to getting your book into the hands of the right
people, and there is so little control you have over that.
I think the truth is that there are no real short cuts to
this publishing thing. You either
struggle to capture an agent or publisher’s attention or self-publish
and struggle to capture consumers’ attention.
Either way, you need to find a way to stand out, and while there may be
tricks to get yourself noticed, you won’t create a buzz unless
you’ve written something that really resonates with readers. Only then will they talk, tweet, and blog
about it and hopefully, recommend it to their friends.
So no matter what path you choose only one thing truly matters, you need to write one amazing book. J
So what are your thoughts on self-promotion?
~MaryAnn
Tuesday, February 14, 2012
Love, Hate, and Publishing
Being Valentine’s Day, I was going to blog about how Disney’s Tangled is the perfect romance (maybe next week), but this week I have something else on my mind.I just learned about the debacle on Goodreads last month, where YA authors or friends of YA authors commented on what were perceived as snarky reviews (a detailed overview can be found here).
This whole thing reminded me of the YA Mafia incident a few years ago (countered here by Holly Black and here by Justine Larbalestier) where an author and book blogger clashed, and the whole thing resulted in a misconception that YA authors were threatening the careers of aspiring writers/book bloggers who gave their books scathing reviews. Clearly no good comes from authors responding to reviews.
I love Goodreads. I have an account that I never update. I think I’ve written one review, two at the most. I don’t really use Goodreads the way it was intended. But every time I finish a book the first thing I do is go to Goodreads and read through a page or so of reviews. I like to see how other people felt about the book I just read. It’s kind of a way to gage what other readers feel is important in a book. I think of it as research. :)
For the most part, I’ve always found the reviewers at Goodreads to be fair. People are entitled to their own opinions, and as long as there are no personal attacks, I think it is all good. Some reviewers are a little snarky and ranty, and honestly, I think a little lesser of these reviews than I do of those that are more respectful and well-thought out. And the Tempest review that started one of the fiascos was honest and intelligent, in my opinion. The reviewer had an issue with a character, and she clearly demonstrated her point. And whether someone agrees with her or not, she made her point very clear without demonizing the author.
But I have seen some pretty scathing reviews at other sites and on blogs. Some bloggers and reviewers make personal attacks on the authors with some pretty bold claims about who the author is and what the author believes in, like you can really know who someone is from a brief biography and reading one of their novels. Writer John Scalzi wrote an interesting post on being fictionalized.
This to me is the dark side of being published, and the more successful you are, the more people are going to pick on you. And I know there are some writers looking down from their huge piles of money, but that comes at a price. I have to say, I feel kind of bad for Stephenie Meyers. So many people who don’t know her are so mean to her (not her books, but her, personally).Sometimes when I dare to dream that I could actually be successful at this writing thing, I think about how I’d feel if those things were written about me. Would I still think those negative reviews on Goodreads are fair? Would I grind my teeth when people try to psychoanalyze me or claim I’m anti-feminist because my MC doesn’t fit their idea of a strong, independent woman (only a true Mary Sue would be that perfect)? Will my skin be thick enough for this plugged-in culture where everyone has an opinion and the means to share it, and some do so without any regards at all to common courtesy?
I do know that I’ll need a good plan to deal with it. So this is a note to me if my dream ever comes true and I actually get published. I know, dare to dream. :)
1. Don’t read reviews. Reviews are for readers not the author.
2. If you do read a review (cause I know you will), do not respond. I repeat, do not ever respond, ever.
3. If you are so dying to respond that you can’t contain yourself, type it up in word, share it with your friends and family, sleep on it, then delete it in the morning.
4. Remember that tastes vary. Not everyone is going to love your stories, hopefully some will.
5. Remember that some people on the internet do not see other people as people only a faceless mass. This gives them permission to be meaner and ruder than they really are.
6. Surround yourself by supportive friends and family who know the real you and will share in your outrage, but will repeatedly remind you not to break rule number two.
7. Always remember what really matters.
That is my plan of attack. I know it is a little of putting the cart before the horse, but I can’t help indulge in the fantasy every once and a while.
So how about you? How would you deal with the negativity once you are published?
Oh yeah, and Happy Valentine’s Day.
~MaryAnn
Labels:
controversy,
Goodreads,
MaryAnn,
publishing,
YA
Monday, February 6, 2012
Silencing Your Inner Cheerleader
What I'm about to share with you is a lesson in what not to do.
Sigh.
I have had a favorite publisher. My hopes for being published somehow became tied together with this specific publishing company. They are located in my same state, publish books similar to mine, and...I'm embarrassed to admit it now, but I thought for sure my story was good enough for them to accept for publication. So after months of polishing and perfecting The Query Packet of Dreams, I sent it in.
Weeks passed. I'm aware that I should have focused on other things, continued to write, sent in packets to other publishers or agents. I didn't. In truth, I only half-lived, always some part of me focused on where The Query Packet of Awesomeness was at that moment. I even prayed, every night, that the slush reader would come upon The Query Packet, would be well fed, and focused. I prayed that it would get the shot that it deserved.
The weeks passed, and every day I went out to my mailbox, wondering if the envelope had come. I started to get excited. This was taking a long time. A lot longer than their website had indicated. Working as a slush editor made me think that extra time before the rejection, meant that it had survived one round, and The Query Packet had made it's way up the channels. I answered ever unknown caller with a nervous and professional excitement.
"Hello, this is Sheena Boekweg." (sigh) "No I am not interested in a newspaper subscription."
On their website, they said it would take an average of eight weeks to respond. So, after eight weeks, and until twelve weeks I lived in a state of nervous energy, and self doubt, which was quickly silenced by my inner cheerleader telling me (perkily) that The Query Packet was brilliant.
See, most writers have an inner editor, and I have one too. The real damaging voice in my head though, is the inner cheerleader who dresses like a New York Professional, and sounds like my mom. She's the one that gets me in trouble. The one who says "this is brilliant," and then after someone reads it I realize how embarrassed I actually should have been to send it out.
Basically, for twelve weeks, I was waiting for the shoe to drop, and then..oh look.. a falling shoe.
I don't have to tell you the kind and respectful words they used to tell me my baby was ugly, do I?
That inner cheerleader of mine, read those happy positive words in the form letter, and saw the silver lining. They must have liked it, quite a lot, to say something so positive, right?
People say you have to silence your inner editor to get the story out, but the inner cheerleader is worse.
For these reasons:
The inner cheerleader hasn't passed an English test. Never trust the grammar check made by your inner cheerleader. She's no good at grammar, or spelling. Perhaps she can't even read. In fact, she may be blind
The inner cheerleader is sadistic. The more you believe her, the more you need her when reality comes to bite your hiney. Which is good job security when you think about it.
I want to believe her, especially when kind friends or family, echo the words she whispers in my ear.
In fact, one day, that beautiful day when my inner cheerleader will be proven right, she will be my best friend. She will say, "See, I always knew you could do it." and I'll be glad I didn't silence her completely.
Okay...fine...you can stay.
But from here on out, you will have no hand in the editing process. That's the inner editors turn to whisper in my ear.
~Sheena
Sigh.
| I believe! So why is this so heavy? |
Weeks passed. I'm aware that I should have focused on other things, continued to write, sent in packets to other publishers or agents. I didn't. In truth, I only half-lived, always some part of me focused on where The Query Packet of Awesomeness was at that moment. I even prayed, every night, that the slush reader would come upon The Query Packet, would be well fed, and focused. I prayed that it would get the shot that it deserved.
The weeks passed, and every day I went out to my mailbox, wondering if the envelope had come. I started to get excited. This was taking a long time. A lot longer than their website had indicated. Working as a slush editor made me think that extra time before the rejection, meant that it had survived one round, and The Query Packet had made it's way up the channels. I answered ever unknown caller with a nervous and professional excitement.
"Hello, this is Sheena Boekweg." (sigh) "No I am not interested in a newspaper subscription."
On their website, they said it would take an average of eight weeks to respond. So, after eight weeks, and until twelve weeks I lived in a state of nervous energy, and self doubt, which was quickly silenced by my inner cheerleader telling me (perkily) that The Query Packet was brilliant.
See, most writers have an inner editor, and I have one too. The real damaging voice in my head though, is the inner cheerleader who dresses like a New York Professional, and sounds like my mom. She's the one that gets me in trouble. The one who says "this is brilliant," and then after someone reads it I realize how embarrassed I actually should have been to send it out.
Basically, for twelve weeks, I was waiting for the shoe to drop, and then..oh look.. a falling shoe.
I don't have to tell you the kind and respectful words they used to tell me my baby was ugly, do I?
That inner cheerleader of mine, read those happy positive words in the form letter, and saw the silver lining. They must have liked it, quite a lot, to say something so positive, right?
People say you have to silence your inner editor to get the story out, but the inner cheerleader is worse.
For these reasons:
The inner cheerleader hasn't passed an English test. Never trust the grammar check made by your inner cheerleader. She's no good at grammar, or spelling. Perhaps she can't even read. In fact, she may be blind
The inner cheerleader is sadistic. The more you believe her, the more you need her when reality comes to bite your hiney. Which is good job security when you think about it.
I want to believe her, especially when kind friends or family, echo the words she whispers in my ear.
In fact, one day, that beautiful day when my inner cheerleader will be proven right, she will be my best friend. She will say, "See, I always knew you could do it." and I'll be glad I didn't silence her completely.
Okay...fine...you can stay.
But from here on out, you will have no hand in the editing process. That's the inner editors turn to whisper in my ear.
~Sheena
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



