Thursday, September 20, 2012

Upping the ante


Fantasy, as a genre has its great strengths – new worlds, interesting systems of magic, sweeping adventure. But it also has its problems.  For example, the world tends to end a lot. Think Lord of the Rings. The Avengers. Stephen King’s Dark Tower series. The Stand. Most Stephen King novels, actually.

This is especially problematic in fantasy series. I first started thinking about this while I was reading the sixth book in Jim Butcher’s Harry Dresden series.  I mean, I’m only on the sixth book, and I think Harry has saved the world from ending about three times so far.

Frankly, the overall ubiquity of world-ending plotlines makes the whole thing a little boring, and can take away from the tension. Some writers try to up it by making this the end of all existence. One wonders where they'll go from there: the end of existence, and you still have to do laundry first?

So  how do you keep upping the tension and the stakes in a series, without falling into the end of the world trap? (Or the Anita Blake trap –how many new men will Anita add to her harem this time??) I think it's important to remember that the world doesn't have to end for people to care about characters or a plot. There are so many smaller things that can end. Our lives and identities can be very fragile - how much would it take for your character's life to end as he/she knows it? Or their loved one's life? That, in my mind, creates as much tension as any global crisis.



It took a lot less space to say that than I thought it would, so to round out the post, here's a picture of  some ducklings:

From flickr, shared under a creative commons license. Taken by www.thegoodlifefrance.com



12 comments:

  1. Awww - those ducklings are adorable! You wouldn't believe it, but I was thinking about this same thing just yesterday. I'm searching for a 'pushing-factor' for my new WIP and the first thing that popped into my head was 'destruction on mankind.' But how boring is that? EVERYONE seems to use it. Amazing that the world could exist so long ;)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I found a Windows 7 duckling theme for my work computer. I save it for those really, really awful, stressful days.

      It is amazing how our world persists, isn't it? And people make such noise about small potential changes - that's been on my mind a lot during election season. Perhaps I should spend much more time as a writer contemplating how even tiny changes could end in disaster.

      On the other hand, a villain whose evil plan is to make sure that supermarkets no longer exist just doesn't carry the same weight, does it?

      Delete
  2. It's almost like we were thinking about the same post. Except not. :) Great post, Sabrina!

    ReplyDelete
  3. All stories are about world ending. Perhaps it's only the main characters "personal world" that will end but it's all the same.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Right, but it's the physical world ending that can get tiresome. There are so many different ways that our personal worlds can end. Ending of the social life, loss of a loved one, threats to our individuality, threats to our identity... those possibilities don't, to me, get old.

      Delete
  4. Very thought provoking post. I know that teens love to feel that they can change the world (I certainly did), and I think that may be one reason why the 'save the world/crush the dystopian government/defeat the evilest evil ever' memes in YA lit resonate so much. It gives power to their dreams.
    Great post!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That was certainly true for me as well; I dreamed of changing the world. But I love the way you phrase that, to give power to their dreams. Thinking about it in that way will keep me occupied for the weekend!

      Delete
  5. Reminds me of a line in Buffy that really stood out to me: one of the characters (I don't remember which) says they never thought they would need to know the plural for 'apocalypse.'

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh man, I totally forgot about that. Lines like those have always been my favorite part of Joss Whedon's shows.

      Delete
  6. It's sad when a story is cookie-cutter "protagonist vs antagonist with the fate of the world hanging in the balance," but Adam's right. It might only be the character's world at stake, but ultimately that's what boils down to.

    ReplyDelete
  7. All problems can be solved with pictures of cute ducks. :)

    I totally agree with you. Sometimes I find saving the world stakes boring. I don't care that much about an imaginary world. Personal stakes are much more interesting, IMO.

    I do love how Buffy the Vampire Slayer made fun of all their impending Apocalypses, but all their world endings also contained personal stakes for Buffy and her friends. I love Buffy.

    ReplyDelete

Got an opinion? Use it! Remember... be silly, be honest, and be nice/proofread.