I still remember what my grandma sent me for Christmas in 2000. I remember, because it was the first time anyone had given me a book the size of a dictionary for Christmas, and I had some seriously mixed feelings about it. I'd never heard of the book--in fact, I must have been living under a rock up to that point, because at 16 years old, I'd never heard of the Harry Potter series whatsoever. Who was this
Harry Potter and why did his goblet have fire in it? Didn't he know goblets were for drinking?
The number 4 on the spine discouraged me. I couldn't just jump into a series with book 4! It took a few months to work up the desire to find books 1-3, but eventually I got around to it, and soon I was hooked.
A lot has changed since I took my first tentative steps into the world of Young Adult. Christopher Paolini opened the door to teen writers, something Steph Bowe has since repeated. Stephenie Meyer gave us Twilight, and made it okay to be an adult YA reader. The Hunger Games made violence and death par for the course. In my last blog post, I questioned whether Warm Bodies was classified as YA because of the violence, drug use, sex and swearing, and it turns out that yes, it is. So what do all those changes mean for us writers?
When I started writing YA (about ten years ago now...gasp!) I ran into a lot of roadblocks and rules. Teens can't swear. They can't have graphic fights. Kissing was about as far as anyone was willing to go in the romance subplots. Even the subject matter had to be chosen carefully. The main character couldn't have a drug problem, but the best friend
could. That way the reader could get a glimpse at the dark side of the world, without being put smack dab in the middle of it. Today, however, the rules have changed.
Last year, BYU professor Sarah Coyne conducted a
study to determine the level of profanity in YA books. She pulled 40 samples from an adolescent best seller list, and many were shocked at her findings. I, personally, have read enough YA in the last decade that it didn't surprise me in the least to hear that, on average, the books contained 38 instances of swearing from cover to cover. However, the study has lead many to question whether YA books should come with warnings on the covers, to better help parents choose which books their teens should be reading. (I'm not going into the moral debate that idea creates. If you want to read an article containing the ALA's response, you can find it
here. This is another article, which takes an opposing view to the study and the BYU publication. There. Balanced information. My job is done!)
Profanity isn't the only thing popping up in droves. The evolution of the Harry Potter books themselves shows how dark and violent the world of YA is becoming. If you need a really controversial example of what's being published under the YA banner, check out Nic Sheff's book
Tweak: Growing Up on Methamphetamines. If you weren't convinced before how quickly things are changing, that book will open your eyes.
It's not particularly new for teens to be exposed to violence and swearing. Video games, movies, even cartoons have been a part of our culture for decades. Before that, comic books. Before
that, fairy tales. Ever sat down and thought about the story of the three little pigs? At least two of the pigs get eaten, people. Talking, house-building pigs, reduced to bacon. Or what about the original Little Mermaid? Disney put a pretty spin on the ending, but earlier versions have the prince sailing off into the sunset with a different woman, turning the mermaid into sea foam. (Undine, considered to be the myth that spawned the mermaid story, ended up killing her husband and his lover. Talk about murderous revenge.) For some reason, it's only
just now beginning to catch up in modern adolescent literature.
 |
| Love the portrait of dad, guys |
One boundary that is getting pushed more slowly than the others is sex. The level of sexual explicitness in Harry Potter can be summed up with one word: snogging. Twilight acknowledges a teenager's desires, but makes marriage a prerequisite before fading to black. Becca Fitzpatrick and Cassandra Clare give their characters opportunities to sleep together, in the most literal sense, but both provide barriers to going any further. But other authors have crossed the invisible line. Kristin Cashore's characters in Graceling aren't having any babies, and the writing is fairly obscure, but it tiptoes just over the line that some writers (and readers) consider "safe."
Andrea Creamer, author of the wildly popular
Nightshade series, took a stance supporting her use of sex and violence in YA books in
an essay for the Wall Street Journal. At one point she says,
"Teens don't live in a vacuum. They inhabit the same brutal world as adults without the knowledge and tools of adulthood. They're looking for help to gain those skills."
Simon and Schuster has spearheaded an interesting new online feature. When Abbi Glines first wrote
The Vincent Boys she had more than a few explicit sexual scenes. Simon Pulse, a division of Simon and Schuster, chose to cut the scenes for the print version, marketing the book to teens, but later added them as online-only content intended "for mature readers only." The aim of this online campaign? To cater to the cross-over readers who want the excitement of YA plot and the steamy romance of an E. L. James. Does this dual publication set a new standard for YA?
Not necessarily.
Another genre is emerging from all this debate and boundary-pushing. New Adult, supposedly a genre to bridge the cross-over gap, is gaining a following in the publishing world. I don't think that means we'll see YA settle back into the safe world of
fade to black and
"oh fudge!" The line has been crossed, and we can't go back. But hopefully with New Adult garnering shelf space in bookstores, there is room for both kinds of stories. Writers that previously struggled to find their place in the YA world won't have to censor their plots and dialogue, while other writers can tell a great story without feeling societal pressures to spice things up with sex and violence.
Ultimately it's the author's job to guide her readers through her story. We've been given a huge canvas on which to paint our scenes, but that just means we have a bigger responsibility to our readers. Teenagers especially need to know that no matter how bad things get in a story--no matter how violent, how dark, how awful--there is always hope.
Maybe that was the most important YA rule all along.
How about a little steampunk train fantasy which feels just a wee bit science fictiony? My kids and I really enjoyed The Mark of the Dragonfly by Jaleigh Johnson this spring, and it's worth a look for readers of all types.
What else is out there? In fantasy, we adore the Magic Thief series by Sarah Prineas, and this fall a fourth book in the series came out, called Magic Thief Home. This one is great for younger readers, too. My kids began reading this series around 2nd grade. There are a few dark bits but not too much, and the books tend to end on a hopeful or upbeat note.
